Trials
These case studies underscore the practical benefits and value of Greenwater Service’s services, showcasing their ability to address complex water quality issues effectively. Their technology is particularly noted for being chemical-free and environmentally friendly, making it a sustainable choice for water treatment projects.
Lake Newport, Ohio
Another successful application of their technology was in Lake Newport, where NBOT treatments led to a noticeable improvement in both the chemical makeup and visual clarity of the water. This project highlighted the capability of NBOT to tackle issues related to harmful algae and toxins efficiently.
Lake Newport before treatment
Lake Newport after treatment
Port Mayaca Lock & Dam, Florida
Greenwater Services has been engaged in a three-year study with institutions like The Ohio State University and the University of Florida. This study aims to validate the effectiveness of NBOT in treating red-tide algae blooms and other water contaminants. Initial results have shown significant improvements in water quality and reduction of harmful algae and toxins.
1. Total treatment time was very short – only two (2) twelve hour treatment periods were possible with normal boat traffic in between treatments. This limited time had the potential to skew or negatively impact results. However, the observations actually paralleled textbook results. At the time “0”, 20 gallons of pre-treatment water were removed from the lock and assessed for algae and algaltoxins. The algae cell counts were so high they count not be counted. Algae cells were predominantly (>97%) microcystis. 1 liter of the 20 gallon sample was removed and extracted. In this extract, large amounts of microcystin LR toxins were observed. An estimated 400mg of toxins in the 20 gallon sample, which is an extremely high level of contamination.
2. At 12 hours, there was roughly a 90% reduction in algae cells, much more than anticipated. No algal cells were observed in the 24-hour and 36-hour samples. Despite the lock being opened for boat traffic, which allowed for “new” water and algae exchange, it appears as though the nano-bubbles from the initial treatment were still active. At 72 hours, the lock was virtually clear of observable algae. Our laboratory results show no traces of mcirocystin LR toxin in the 24-hour and36-hour samples. This result was anticipated as cyclic peptides (e.g.; microcystin LR toxin) have shown to be highly susceptible to treatment.
3. Further experiments were conducted on the 20 gallon sample to measure the effects on Nitrogen and Phosphorus levels. Both showed significant reductions which is critical since algae growth is dependent on a fairly fixed ratio or these nutrients. By significantly reducing Nitrogen and Phosphorus levels, future algae growth will be minimized.
4. On site measurements showed slight increases in Dissolved Oxygen (“DO”) levels in the 3-5ppm range as well as a significant decrease in turbidity, an indicator of water clarity. There was no reported fish death or any negative impact on wildlife. An increase in fish and wildlife activity was observed (i.e.; fish jumping, water fowl more prevalent), which is expected with increased DO levels.
Youngstown State University Biological Assessment
Results: The data demonstrate that the addition of crude algal toxin extracts obtained from untreated water samples (pre-treatment) significantly reduced the cell viability of all cell lines after 48 h (white bars, cells with toxins), with 60% for skin, 50% for lung and 45% for liver cells as compared to the controls, cells to which no toxin extracts were added (cell viability at 100%) (cells without toxins, closed bars). Algal toxin extracts obtained from NBOT-treated water samples increased the cell viability of all the cell lines as compared to untreated water. Generally, when comparing pre-treatment samples and those with NBOT treatment, there was an increase in cell viability for each location sampled on skin, lung and liver cells. demonstrating that the toxic activity of the toxin extracts obtained from NBOT-treated water samples is reduced, resulting in an increase in cell viability following NBOT treatment.
Conclusion: The obtained results demonstrate that untreated water (pre-treatment) samples contain algal toxins that are harmful to several cell lines, reducing the cell viability with 45 to 60%. Additionally, the findings suggest that NBOT treatment likely destroys algal toxins and resulting in increased cell viability.
Sylvan Lake
Lake Sylvan is a 60-acre lake west of Columbus, OH. We worked with Ohio State on a project, funded by USACE, to treat Lake Sylvan in July and August of 2021.
The reduction in cyanobacteria throughout the lake shows how the bubbles travel and reduce cyanobacteria over the entire lake and how effective they are compared to the control of Grand Lake St Mary’s.
Grand Lake St. Mary Beach Trial
The treated beach was open for the summer and consistently had lower toxin levels than beaches on either side.
Mesocosm Trial
The mesocosm trial, there were actually 2, one in 2022 and one in 2023. We went to Stone Lab's mesocosm, located at the Ohio State's research facility at Put-N-Bay just off of lake Erie. The results you see on the graph comparing high and low doses of ozone vs algaecides and their effects on non target organisms was in 2022 and the graph showing the 5 green tanks with control, oxygen, low, medium and high doses of ozone which correspond to 30, 60 and 120 g/hr doses of ozone was done in 2023.
Visual Results from 2023 Mesocosm Trial, 72 Hours after Treatment
Planktothrix dominant bloom sourced from Grand Lakes Saint Marys and amended (diluted) with filtered Lake Erie water.
Preliminary Data Courtesy Ohio State University and University of Florida.